48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (2024)

by Katie Adams 19 Comments

Explore 48 Best Recipes for Cookie Cups, elevating cookies with simple, delightful variations that are sure to impress and satisfy!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (1)

Welcome to the delightful world of cookie cups! If you're new to this treat, you might wonder, what exactly is a cookie cup?

Well, it's a fantastic take on the traditional cookie. Rather than baking them flat and round on a sheet, these cookies are baked in mini muffin tins.

And here's the best part: these cookie cups can be filled with all sorts of delicious goodies, from pudding and cheesecake to fruit and candy.

Get ready to elevate your cookie experience!

Delicious Recipes for Cookie Cups

Visit the website for the step-by-step recipe tutorial. All links will open in the same tab.

1. Bite-Sized Peanut Butter Cookie Cup from Baking Bites

Enjoy Bite-Sized Peanut Butter Cup Cookies, a perfect blend of candy and cookie for a deliciously sweet treat. Ideal for snack time or dessert!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (2)

2. Chocolate Chip Cookie Brownie Melts from Homemade in the Kitchen

Indulge in Chocolate Chip Cookie Brownie Melts, a delightful fusion of cookies and brownies in one bite-sized treat, packed with rich flavor!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (3)

3. Funfetti Cheesecake Cookie Cups from SBA

When you can’t decide between cheesecake, sprinkles, or chocolate chip cookies for dessert… have all three!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (4)

4. Lemon Bar Cookie Cups from Barbara Bakes

Indulge in Lemon Bar Cookie Cups, a convenient twist on classic lemon bars. Perfect for lemon lovers, they're simple to make and even easier to enjoy!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (5)

5. Gnome Cookie Cups from Just is a Four Letter Word

Enjoy Gnome Cookie Cups any time of year! These adorable treats are perfect alongside your favorite Christmas cookies or as a delightful snack.

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (6)

6. Salted Caramel Browned Butter Cookie Cups from Buns in My Oven

Indulge in warm, gooey Salted Caramel Browned Butter Cookie Cups. Best served warm for a melt-in-your-mouth experience. Reheat easily for a quick, delicious treat!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (7)

7. Ice Cream Cookie Cups from Project Nursery

Enjoy easy-to-make Ice Cream Cookie Cups using refrigerated dough for a delightful, homemade treat. Perfect for quick, delicious cookie creations!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (8)

8. Mini Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie Cups from Life Love and Sugar

Indulge in Mini Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie Cups - a heavenly blend of chewy strawberry cookies and no-bake cheesecake. Irresistibly delicious!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (9)

9. Mini Berry Tarts from Lovely Little Kitchen

Delight guests with Mini Berry Tarts, ideal for brunches or showers. Easy to make, these crowd-pleasers always have everyone asking for the recipe!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (10)

10. Salted Caramel Cookie Cups from Easy Baked

Indulge in Salted Caramel Cookie Cups, where crunchy pretzel meets sweet chocolate and creamy caramel for a delightful salty-sweet treat.

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (11)

11. Blueberry S'more Cookie Cups from Big Bang Bites

Sugar cookie delights oozing with blueberry filling, topped with toasted marshmallows. A unique twist on a classic!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (12)

12. Turtle Cookie Cups from Whole and Heavenly Oven

Indulge in Turtle Cookie Cups, blending classic turtle candy flavors into bite-sized, soft, chewy delights. Ideal for holidays or anytime treats!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (13)

13. Strawberry Mousse Sugar Cookie Cups from Cookies and Cups

Savor the perfection of Strawberry Mousse Sugar Cookie Cups, a delightful blend of sweet mousse and crisp cookies in a bite-sized treat.

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (14)

14. Lemon Meringue Cookie Cups from Mom On Time Out

Savor the blend of sugar cookie cups and tart lemon curd in these delightful Lemon Meringue Cookie Cups, a perfect sweet treat!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (15)

15. Apple Crisp Cookie Cups from Liv For Cake

Apple Crisp Cookie Cups are a delicious combination of classic oatmeal cookies and homemade apple pie filling, making them the perfect comfort food.

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (16)

16. Smores Chocolate Chip Cookie Cups from Chocolate Moosey

Smores Chocolate Chip Cookie Cups are the perfect treat for a summer cookout. The combination of smores and chocolate chip cookies is irresistible.

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (17)

17. Boston Cream Pie Cookie Cups from Life Love and Sugar

Boston Cream Pie Cookie Cups are delicious and fun little cookies made with a vanilla cookie base, custard filling, and chocolate ganache topping.

18. Cherry Pie Cookie Cups from Lemon Tree Dwelling

Cherry Pie Cookie Cups are a quick and delicious solution for satisfying a craving for cherry pie. These bite-sized desserts can be prepared in just 5 minutes!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (19)

19. White Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies from Shugary Sweets

White Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies are delicious cookie cups with a White Chocolate Reese's cup inside.

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (20)

20. Dark Chocolate Andes Cookie Cups from Beyond Frosting

The delightful blend of rich dark chocolate and refreshing mint makes it an irresistible treat. This delectable combination is perfect for any time of the year.

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (21)

21. Coconut Pineapple Mango Cookie Cups from Barbara Bakes

Delightful little treats made by rolling oatmeal cookie dough in coconut and filling it with pineapple-mango jam.

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (22)

22. Hot Chocolate Cookie Cups from Princess Pinky Girl

Hot Chocolate Cookie Cups are a delightful holiday treat perfect for Christmas parties, cookie exchanges, or simply bringing joy to someone's day!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (23)

23. Frosted Cookie Cups from My Chocolate Therapy

Frosted Cookie Cups are a universally loved dessert, thanks to the perfect combination of cookie and icing in every bite.

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (24)

24. Fruit Cheesecake Sugar Cookie Cups from Live Laugh and Sugar

Fruit Cheesecake Sugar Cookie Cups are a fun twist on classic sugar cookies, filled with no-bake cheesecake and topped with fresh fruit.

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (25)

25. Chocolate Chip Cookie Cups Ala Mode from Wishes and Dishes

Indulge in jumbo Chocolate Chip Cookie Cups a la mode. These cupcake-sized treats are filled with dark chocolate ice cream and drizzled with strawberry syrup.

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (26)

26. Tiramisu Cookie Cups from All Day I Dream About Food

Savor creamy tiramisu filling in coffee-flavored cookie cups. These keto-friendly treats are perfect finger-food indulgence.

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (27)

27. Cookie Cups from Lady and the Blog

Try this cookie cup recipe for a creative twist on cookies and milk. It's a fun and delightful dessert that your children will adore!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (28)

28. Blueberry Pie Cookies from Owl Baking

Indulge in these delectable blueberry pie cookies - a quick, flavorful twist on classic blueberry pie, perfectly sized for party desserts!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (29)

29. Pecan Pie Cookie Cups from Easy Baked

Delight in these scrumptious pecan pie cookie cups, featuring dark chocolate and pecans in a soft sugar cookie cup. Yum!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (30)

30. Chocolate Peppermint Cookie Cups from Liv For Cake

Indulge in the holiday spirit with Chocolate Peppermint Cookie Cups. Dark chocolate cookies filled with whipped peppermint cheesecake and candy cane toppings!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (31)

31. Chocolate Cookie Dough Cookie Cups from Sweetest Menu

Satisfy your sweet tooth with these Cookie Dough Cookie Cups filled with homemade chocolate chip dough and drizzled in more chocolate. Irresistible!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (32)

32. Banana Split Cookie Cups from Let's Dish

Indulge in the flavors of a classic banana split with these mini sugar cookie cups filled with your favorite toppings. A fun and tasty treat!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (33)

33. S'mores Cookie Cups from Lemon Tree Dwelling

Satisfy your s'mores cravings with these delightful sugar cookie cups filled with marshmallows, chocolate, and graham cracker bits, toasted to perfection!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (34)

34. Sugar Cookie Cups with Cheesecake Filling and Fresh Fruit from The Kitchen Whisperer

Indulge in guilt-free delight with these stunning sugar cookie cups, brimming with creamy cheesecake filling and topped with fresh, colorful fruit.

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (35)

35. Buckeye Bites from Mom On Time Out

Whip up a crowd-pleasing batch of Buckeye Bites! These sweet chocolate cookie cups are filled with creamy peanut butter and crowned with a luscious chocolate ganache.

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (36)

36. Butterfinger Cookie Cups from Dinners, Dishes, and Desserts

Savor golden chocolate chip cookie cups brimming with mini Butterfinger candies - a delightful treat for your taste buds!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (37)

37. Raspberry Cream Tartlets from Flour Arrangements

Indulge in the perfect pairing of tangy raspberry cream and chocolate cookie crusts with these delightful Raspberry Cream Tartlets, a hit at any party!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (38)

38. Oreo Cheesecake Cookie Cups from Liv For Cake

Indulge your love for Oreos with these easy Oreo Cheesecake Cookie Cups, a delightful treat for all Oreo enthusiasts!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (39)

39. Carrot Patch Cookie Cups from Oh My Creative

These Carrot Patch Cookie Cups are not only adorable but also delicious! Perfect for Easter and baby showers with a Peter Rabbit theme.

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (40)

40. Chocolate Chip Cookie Cups from Liv for Cake

Enjoy simple, delicious Chocolate Chip Cookie Cups filled with vanilla cream cheese mousse and chocolate sauce – an easy, delightful treat!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (41)

41. Gingerbread Cheesecake Cookie Cups from Life Love and Sugar

Kick off Christmas with Gingerbread Cheesecake Cookie Cups, featuring soft gingerbread and no-bake brown sugar spiced cheesecake!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (42)

42. Coconut Cream Pie Cookie Cups from The Novice Chef

Enjoy Coconut Cream Pie Cookie Cups, a delightful mix of sugar cookies and coconut cream pie, topped with whipped cream and toasted coconut!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (43)

43. Snickerdoodle Apple Pie Cookie Cups from Family Cookie Recipes

Snickerdoodle Apple Pie Cookie Cups blend cinnamon and apple pie filling in a bite-sized treat, marrying two favorite desserts perfectly!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (44)

44. Peanut Butter and Jelly Cookie Cups from Liv for Cake

Upgrade a classic with Peanut Butter & Jelly Cookie Cups, a simple yet delightful twist on the lunchbox favorite!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (45)

45. Double Dark Chocolate Cookie Cups from Suburban Simplicity

Indulge in Double Dark Chocolate Cookie Cups, crispy outside with a creamy filling, a decadent treat for chocolate aficionados!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (46)

46. Christmas Sprinkle Cookie Cups from Inspired by Charm

Add festive flair to your holiday treats with Christmas Sprinkle Cookie Cups, an easy and colorful recipe perfect for your cookie tray!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (47)

47 . Vanilla Custard Cookie Cups from Liv for Cake

Enjoy Vanilla Custard Cookie Cups, bite-sized sugar cookies filled with smooth vanilla custard, and topped with fresh berries for a sweet treat!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (48)

48. Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Chocolate Chip Cookie Cups from Princess Pinky Girl

Whip up Reese's Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie Bites in just 15 minutes with only TWO ingredients for the world's easiest dessert!

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (49)

What cookie-cup recipe are you going to try first?

Pin for Later:

Our Baking Essential List:

  • For baking casseroles, we use Glass Baking Dishes. I especially like the dishes with lids so leftovers can be transferred straight to the fridge.
  • Silicone Kitchenware is my favorite because they don't scratch my cookware and is easy to clean!
  • A Glass Cutting Board is a must to prepare all of those ingredients. We even keep ours on our counter at all times.
  • This Knife Set will also become your favorite! They cut beautifully, and with the hollow design of the knife, food doesn't stick to the blade.

Recommended Posts

20 Tasty Homemade Cookie Recipes
7 Extraordinary Cookie Recipes
How to Make Orange and Fudge Sandwich Cookie Recipe
How to Make the Best Peanut Butter Cookies Recipe
How to Make Halloween Party Pudding Cups
20 of the Best Oreo Dessert Recipes
25 of the Best Breakfast Waffle Recipes
30 of the Best Bread Maker Recipes
20 Best Milk Chocolate Dessert Recipes
20 Best Roasted Asparagus Recipes - Recipes that will Satisfy
Author Bio
Article Info
Popular Posts
Author Bio

Katie Adams

Creator at The Crafty Blog Stalker

Katie Adams, known as The Crafty Blog Stalker, inspires with her innovative DIY projects and artistic flair. Her blog offers detailed tutorials, tips, and engaging content, encouraging readers to embrace their crafty side. From simple crafts to complex creations, Katie's passion motivates followers to unleash their creativity and make unique pieces. Follow The Crafty Blog Stalker for a world of crafting inspiration and discover the joy of creating something beautiful.

Power Bio Box by Zyra Console

Article Info

You are here: Home Popular 48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups

Title:

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups

Authors:

  • Katie Adams

Categories:

  • Cookie Recipes
  • Popular

Mentions:

Recipes

Keywords:

cookie cup recipes

Last Updated:

February 15, 2024

Popular Posts
  • 29 Fun St. Patrick's Day Crafts for Kids
  • 25 Creative Plastic Easter Egg Crafts
  • Homemade Wind Chimes with Sea Glass
  • How to Make a Yarn Tassel Tree for Christmas Decor
  • 28 Felt Christmas Crafts You Can Make With Simple Instructions
  • DIY Halloween Candy Wrapper with Free SVG
  • How To Frame Diamond Art in 4 Easy Steps
  • 35 DIY Yarn Wall Hanging Crafts With Clear Instructions
  • Does the Listerine Foot Soak Really Work?
  • How to Make 20 Halloween Treat Bag Ideas
  • 20 At Home Science Crafts for Kids
  • 20 Cute Graduation Money Gift Ideas

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Kristina & Millie

    oh my i have to try like all of these 🙂 nom nom nom

    Reply

  2. Trish

    so many in one place!! where do I start? mmmmm... thanks for sharing!!

    Reply

  3. Dawn

    I'm ashamed to say that I've never made cookie cups yet! Not only do they look delish, but they seem like I can actually recreate them... no more intimidation! Thank you for the inspiration and for all the fab ideas 🙂

    Reply

  4. Kat@ Home. Made. Interest.

    Yum!! Now I'm hungry 🙂 Pinning this!

    Reply

  5. Stephanie

    This looks delicious! I would love for you share it on my Tasty Tuesday recipe link up! Everything gets pinned and I would love to have you!

    Reply

  6. Tiffany @ A Touch of Grace

    Love cookie cups! Great compilation of recipes!

    Reply

  7. Charlee Anne

    I never knew there were so many cookie cup recipes out there! They look oh so yummy.

    Reply

  8. Karren Haller

    I was browsing around your blog this morning and found this fun post, never seen so many cookies cups, I was so excited, I pinned it!!

    Reply

  9. Patti

    So. Many. Recipes...pinned and stumbled!

    Reply

  10. Erica loop

    I feel like I might need to go to the gym very soon. Great recipes!

    Reply

  11. Katie

    Shirley, if you click on the image it will take you to the website with the recipe.

    Reply

  12. Amy | The Happy Scraps

    Oh great! Now I'm hungry. 😉 These look delish! Thanks for linking up at The Creative Exchange!

    Reply

  13. Stephanie

    I want to try ALL of these!!! Thank you so much for linking up at Tasty Tuesday! Your recipe has been pinned to the Tasty Tuesday Pinterest board! Please join us again this week!

    Reply

  14. Shanice

    Thank you for sharing this post at City of Creative Dream's City of Links on Friday! I appreciate you taking the time to party with me. Hope to see you again today 🙂

    Reply

  15. Marti

    Yummy!! Pinning 🙂

    Reply

  16. Jadesara

    Wow!! Wonderful tutorial.. Brilliant work..

    Reply

  17. Ngozi

    Wow, thanks. You've made my day
    Back to my morning devotions

    Reply

  18. Mark

    Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU! I havebeen looking forever for recipes to make with the mini muffin pand and tamper that I bought!!

    Reply

    • Katie Adams

      You are welcome! Happy to help ❤️

      Reply

Leave a Reply

48 of the Best Recipes for Cookie Cups - The Crafty Blog Stalker (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Aracelis Kilback

Last Updated:

Views: 5458

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Aracelis Kilback

Birthday: 1994-11-22

Address: Apt. 895 30151 Green Plain, Lake Mariela, RI 98141

Phone: +5992291857476

Job: Legal Officer

Hobby: LARPing, role-playing games, Slacklining, Reading, Inline skating, Brazilian jiu-jitsu, Dance

Introduction: My name is Aracelis Kilback, I am a nice, gentle, agreeable, joyous, attractive, combative, gifted person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.